Hello dear
Welcome To Rick's Crabby Cowboy Cafe
At Rick's Crabby Cowboy Cafe, nestled in scenic Montauk, we share a passion for seafood and community. For over 25 years, this hidden gem has welcomed guests with a casual and inviting atmosphere. Our menu boasts fresh offerings, from the renowned lobster roll to the unforgettable Striper sandwich, delighting diners with flavors that evoke the essence of coastal cuisine. Emphasizing a commitment to health and safety, we ensure a pleasant experience with both outdoor seating and attentive service. Here, we foster connections over delicious food, making every visit a memorable journey of taste and warmth. Join us to savor the magic of Montauk!
About
Rick's Crabby Cowboy Cafe
Welcome to Rick's Crabby Cowboy Cafe, a hidden gem nestled in the picturesque seaside town of Montauk, New York. Located at 435 E Lake Dr, this charming seafood cafe not only boasts stunning views of the harbor but also delights your taste buds with its fresh and flavorful offerings. If you're a seafood lover, this is the place to be.
Upon stepping into Rick's Crabby Cowboy Cafe, you immediately feel the inviting atmosphere. The friendly team led by Rick himself treats you as though you’re part of their family, making your dining experience all the more memorable. Right from the start, you notice that they prioritize safety and cleanliness, adhering strictly to COVID protocols to ensure your peace of mind.
Let’s delve into the menu, where the highlights truly shine. The lobster roll is a fan favorite, crafted with succulent lobster meat tucked into a perfectly toasted bun—a dish that has received praise for its taste and freshness. Many customers, like Stephen S., claimed it was the best they’ve ever had, solidifying Rick's reputation in the local food scene.
Another standout is the Striper sandwich, which has garnered rave reviews from seafood aficionados. As one diner put it, it’s "the absolute best fish sandwich" they’ve ever experienced. At Rick's, freshness is key—many ingredients are locally sourced, ensuring that what you eat is not just good, but truly great.
The cafe isn’t just known for its sandwiches; the Fisherman's Platter also deserves a mention. Featuring a variety of seafood such as shrimp, calamari, and lightly battered fish, this dish satisfies every craving. As Bob B. noted, it's served with fresh marinara and tartar sauces, adding an extra layer of flavor that enhances the seafood experience.
Aside from the exquisite food, one can't help but appreciate the ambiance. Whether you're dining inside or enjoying the fresh air on the patio, you might even spot planes flying overhead from the nearby airport, adding a unique flair to your meal.
In conclusion, Rick's Crabby Cowboy Cafe is a delightful spot for seafood lovers and anyone looking to savor the coastal flavors of Montauk. With its commitment to quality, service, and a cozy environment, it’s clear why guests like Kim K., Stephen S., and Gaudi O. have fallen in love with this charming cafe. Don’t miss out on this culinary experience the next time you're in the area—you'll be hooked!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Came here tonight for dinner when our first choice turned us away and good thing ..this had the same view but was empty. Now I'm sure it was because the wind was crazy tnite but us and one other family were the only people there the whole time. They take Covid very serious. Tons of hand sanitizer, paper menus, they bring out our food to go even if you are staying. The food was good. Corn fritters- delicious, fish sandwich- delicious, greek salad- just ok. I know this place would be amazing in the summer on a busier night! ”
“ OK, so when I find such a wonderful place, especially by surprise, I feel duty-bound to report on how great the find was to me. My girlfriend and I came across this phenomenal, low key, gem while driving around absorbing the beautiful Montauk scenery. It just so happens that it was on a day where the weather appears to have been sent from heaven. We were looking for a place with great views, food, service, and prices. Well we sure found it! Across the board outstanding! We fell in love with this place and its people. Rick is an awesome guy and his team treated you like you were at their home. We even had the good fortune of sitting at the table next to the one and only Bill Murray, which is likely due to his desire to stay low key and still eat at great places. The food was spectacular! I had the Striper sandwich and my girlfriend had the lobster roll. I have been fishing all of my life and it was the absolute best fish sandwich that I have EVER had. My girlfriend said same about her lobster roll. I can't believe that this incredible place has been around for 25 years and we are only just finding now. We will be returning regularly going forward for sure. Shout out and apologies to Rick and his team. Meant to post this right after we were there in June, but life got in the way. ”
“ Perfect time is right when they open which is around noon! Not allot of people if you want to avoid a crowd, seating was available anywhere you basically wanted, service was super quick as well! Ordered the "Fisherman's Platter", everything was delicious, also the lobster roll, and famous onion rings (super crispy!!) Order process is also very simple , you just tell them at the order pick up window where you are seated, waiter (with mask/gloves) brings your food in a big paper bag (napkins, utensils, ketchup packets, wipes included inside) Fun fact: the airport is right next door, you get to see some planes fly overhead while your eating COVID guidelines with mask until seated, there's also hand sanitizer stations all throughout the venue ”
“ What a great experience we had dining here. Tuesday night in the middle our tourist season. Got a great table overlooking the harbor. Wish the tables were closer to the water but oh well. Service was efficient. Food was good all around. Exactly as advertised which is why I'm giving it 5 stars. We got just what we expected and when all 4 of us leave happy, that's a 5 star dinner. ”
“ Started with a perfect plate of steamers. Then the fried fisherman's plate: shrimp, calamari and fish. All lightly battered and cooked perfectly. I'm glad I ate here! With fresh marinara and tartar sauces. ”
“ My family has been coming here every summer for years. (since I was a kid) During the winter we talk about this place like its the promised land and if I go without them, I brag about my meal the next day. There is something for everyone on this menu! We have two picky eaters in the family and they always find something they want. The fish always tastes fresh & the BBQ is always good! Great drink menu with a full service bar as well. The waitstaff is very friendly & you always feel welcomed here. After your meal you can take tour drinks outside to enjoy a beautiful view of the lake & boats, play a game of corn hole, or sit by the fire and roast s'mores. If you're lucky you'll be able to watch a little plane fly right over this place and land at the airport right across the street! Overall great place! ”
“ I come here regularly during the summer. It's one of those perfect summer pilot spots ... Fly into Montauk and walk across the road to Rick's. My favorite is the lobster roll. I consider Rick's rolls among the best I've had. Lots of lobster meat, just the right amount of mayo, and the softest potato buns lightly toasted. Fries are always hot and crispy. I love been enjoying rather steamers too, and today I had their delicious NE clam chowder, that also was just right balance of creamy and thick. Eating outside on the inner harbor is just about perfect with a nice summer breeze. Under the tent on the super-hot days takes the sting out. 5 stars is what I give Rick for the consistently yummy lunch stop with friends and family when we visit Montauk. ”
